Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
Share KSS on:
Welcome to Kurdistan sky scrapers forum. Hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Add Reply
MENDELI - SOUTH KURDISTAN
Topic Started: 1st February 2013 - 06:52 AM (6,599 Views)
Qandil
No Avatar


Woha. What's this hostile attitude guys? Don't accuse each other of silly things. I think the only way to know the situation there, is to wait for the upcoming election. When will this election be held, heval Alan?
OfflineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
FeyliKurd
No Avatar
Alîşerwanî

Please guys we should not make a big deal out of this. I know there are a lot of emotions involved in this topic, but at least we should keep the discussion away from accusations and insults.
OfflineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


i was discussing things in a normal way until he started called me "dyako", which i find very disappointing from him.
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


Shirwan
4th February 2013 - 01:57 AM
Alan
4th February 2013 - 01:51 AM

Quoting limited to 2 levels deep
Atleast I'm not accusing someone of lying, and there is no information on Mandali election vote, but I'm sure you think they voted for Arab parties as Faylis are Arabs.



again more of your word put into my mouth :(. i already stated that most kurds from there have left to KRG "lately" and some were deported during saddam which should have made you understand i was referring to the city deserted to arabs i didnt say kurds are majority there and are voting for arabs!! if you can find a map of 2010 elections you will see that majority are arabs and would have voted for milki, while the minority kurds there would have voted for KRG. and feylis are arabs ? really? grow up jj this is not RBK no more. no need for these kind of silly talks :(

OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
FeyliKurd
No Avatar
Alîşerwanî

But heval, you must try to see it from our perspective as well. Many of us Feylis have friends and relatives in this city and therefore it becomes very sensitive when someone says that "the city is lost to the Arabs"...

I'm not saying you're wrong heval ... Maybe the city is lost. Just trying to explain how some of us feel about it.
OfflineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Alan
4th February 2013 - 02:28 AM
Shirwan
4th February 2013 - 01:57 AM

Quoting limited to 2 levels deep
again more of your word put into my mouth . i already stated that most kurds from there have left to KRG "lately" and some were deported during saddam which should have made you understand i was referring to the city deserted to arabs i didnt say kurds are majority there and are voting for arabs!! if you can find a map of 2010 elections you will see that majority are arabs and would have voted for milki, while the minority kurds there would have voted for KRG. and feylis are arabs ? really? grow up jj this is not RBK no more. no need for these kind of silly talks :(
I'm wrong? So your saying I'm lying? See you don't admit it, but whatever man. I don't care what you think, because you have never been there nor know any Mandlawanis.

And wait your saying I'm making things up? When you made a sweeping statement about Arabs living in Mandali, when you have shown me nothing. And I told you for the millionith time I have no information on the elections there, , but neither do you.
And you did say there is no Kurdish flag in Mandali before, when I and FeyliKurd disproved that. Then you said "that is old", so implying it got taken down by Kurds. But again you haven't any proof, so your just making assumptions. I'm not sure why you are so adament on disproving me based on Jalawa and Sadyeam because they are insigificant towns. Yet you also assume that Kurds who got deported by Saddam didn't return, which actually you'll find in 2003 they did.

I don't know if you understand the concept of sarcasm, but that is exactly what I was doing in regards to Kirkuk being Arab, because it applies in the same context as Kirkuk. Now please show me elections of Mandalis or demographics if you can? Last time I checked Kurdish majority.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

FeyliKurd
4th February 2013 - 02:35 AM
But heval, you must try to see it from our perspective as well. Many of us Feylis have friends and relatives in this city and therefore it becomes very sensitive when someone says that "the city is lost to the Arabs"...

I'm not saying you're wrong heval ... Maybe the city is lost. Just trying to explain how some of us feel about it.
This is what I'm saying, only last year I went on holiday to SK and Iraq, there were many Mandalwanis who were with me and went on a trip.tour with me. From my examination Mandalwanis as a whole aren't KRG orienated, not in the sense of being anti or pro-Krg, but in the sense of being more aligned towards Ilam. Because Mandalwanis also have many families and tribal villages in Ilam. Trust me Mandalwanis can cross the Iranian/Iraqi border easily.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


FeyliKurd
4th February 2013 - 02:35 AM
But heval, you must try to see it from our perspective as well. Many of us Feylis have friends and relatives in this city and therefore it becomes very sensitive when someone says that "the city is lost to the Arabs"...

I'm not saying you're wrong heval ... Maybe the city is lost. Just trying to explain how some of us feel about it.
i know that is why i am trying to alert you guys about this since you seems to know lil about, i am on the hunt for the kurdsat report.
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Posted Image
Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


what i mean is by the town lost to arabs is that arabs now out number kurds, im not saying there is no kurds left, but like Jalawla and Sadiya which are feyli towns as well, kurds are now become minorities :(

here is an article on Jalawla and Sadiya another feyli town which is (closer) to KRG than Mendeli by 50-100 kms.

http://www.kurdishglobe.net/display-article.html?id=F66F9597515F0A7E621EDB93D04C65D4
Quote:
 

Kurds vanish in Jalawla

The Kurdish Globe

By Rawaz Koyee--Erbil

Locals request Kurdistan's Peshmarga forces
Kurdish residents in the disputed areas of Jalawla and Sadiya suffer, they say, as they are targeted and fear for their lives. Many families have left the area. Local Kurdish officials asked for help from the Peshmarga forces.

As with controversial Kirkuk, Kurds claim Jalawla and Sadiya as part of the Kurdistan Region. Yet the areas still witness continuous demographic changes, rising Kurds worry.
"When I left the town, there were about only 7,000 people; now it is more than 80,000," Adnan Shahab said after returning to his homeland after 35 years. He is astonished at this increase in population.

Shahab remembers the early 1970s in his town before he left the country. At that time "nearly 80 percent of the residents were Kurds, alongside Arab families who were living in tents four kilometers away from the town center," he remarked.

Many Arab families were encouraged by the former Iraqi regime to settle in the area while Kurds were deported under the so-called operation of Arabization.

The area is included under the rule of the Iraqi Constitution Article 140 which returns residents not from the area to their original areas and then the people vote on whether to be part of Kurdistan Region.

However, Arabs currently buy 10 times more houses in Jalawla than Kurds do, a real estate dealer told The Kurdish Globe on the condition of anonymity, due to security reasons.

More than 1,000 Kurdish families have left Jalawla since 2003, fleeing the threat of violence, while three or four times this number of Arab families have settled there, said Jalawla Mayor Anwer Hussein, a Kurd.

"You will not find a single Kurd in the town in the coming year, every day, two or three Kurdish families leave," warned the mayor, asking the Kurdistan Region Government to take an immediate stance.

He explained that Kurds leave because of threats by Al Qaeda and Naqshabandi armed groups.

The Kurds had a safer life when the Kurdish Peshmarga forces were in the area in 2008, according to locals. The Kurdish troops were forced out because of disagreements between Erbil and Baghdad.

"It was a historic mistake, as it left the Kurds as easy prey for terrorist attacks," said Hussein.

A delegation from Kurdistan Parliament visited Khanaqin on August 10 to investigate the situation in Jalawla and Sadiya.

Salar Mahmoud, a member of the delegation, told the Globe the conditions are getting worse for the Kurds in Jalawla and Sadiya. "In our report to Parliament, we will ask to return the Kurdish Peshmarga forces to the disputed areas," he said.


Iraqi forces

A Kurdish member of the Iraqi Parliament accused some officers in the Iraqi army of being involved in the violence against the Kurds of the area.

The Jalawla mayor declined to comment on this issue, but he complained the 2,000 Iraqi troops deployed were not able to restore security to his town. "The coordination between some of the Iraqi officers with the armed groups made the people here not to trust the Iraqi forces anymore," he further added.

Journalist Irfan Dawdi, who frequently visits Jalawla, explained that the Iraqi army soldiers are also targets, which is why they cannot always act decisively.

"One of my friends was shot only 30 meters away from an Iraqi forces, vehicle. When I asked whether they will arrest the shooter, they said they have no authority to arrest anyone, they did not dare to approach him," the journalist says of what he witnessed.
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


jj thinks i am bragging about this, no heval I AM WORRIED that is why i am trying to create an awareness on here. which jj seems to have taken the whole thing in the wrong direction, which is that he thinks i dont want Feyli lands to be part of KRG.
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
RawandKurdistani
No Avatar
Surchi/Xoshnawi

Guys stop this fighting already. We are already hated by, Turks, Iraqis, Iranians, Syrians, Assyrians, some Kurds on RBK etc. And now we are up against eachother here too. That's really sad you know :(
OfflineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Ok look I'm sorry, maybe I saw things differently. But heval you are wrong and I say that whole-heartdly. Mandali is different to Jalawa, because as I said Kurds migrate back and forth from Ilam, and Kurds as I said can cross the border. I am not aware of Mandalis moving out of Mandali on mass, I've only heard of a few Mandali families moving to Baghdad and the KRG. In regards to Baghdad, move related to economic reasons, because other tribesmen can help them. However please show me any source that says Kurds in Mandali are minority. I will ask my dad heval and he knows people there directly, and if you think I'm wrong or liar, I'm sure my dad isn't. The only Arabs in the area are Sunnis who aren't in Mandali and the Kurds there even Malikis forces would side with us rather than them, for religious reasons ovbiously, but the point is even with Peshmerga there is still no great impact on demographics in Mandali that has been reported.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


no hard feelings on my end, you were thinking about the whole argument in the different way i started realized it after your angry posts lol.

but that article shows kurds are becoming a minority in those two feyli towns as they dont fall under KRG unfortunately , by logic how can such towns which are on the outskirts of KRG turn out this way while Mendeli so far away fro KRG can hold its Kurdish majority up? arabs have been pouring into it like crazy and there is no Kurdish forces to stop it like they do to Khanaqin and Kirkuk.

after milki ordered Kurdish flags to be lowered from Khanqain which "falls" under KRG, he made Kurdish flags removed from Jalawla, Sadiya and Mendeli, then a kurdsat tv crew went to Mendeli and they were stopped by the local police in Mendeli for like 2 hours till Talabani intervened, these 3 towns which are the only 3 Kurdish towns that do not fall under KRG, Hawija is Kurdish too but has now been lost to arabs and you will see 0 kurdish flags there without even milki asking for them to be removed. and since there is no Pesh there to stop arabization, it will get worst day by day to a point of no return.

i dont know what the chances are to save Mendeli from Ilam, but for now Ilam too is occupied, (not persionaized) but occupied. dont go all crazy on me for this one too :hi:

edit: you should have known from my threads about Khanaqin on RBK and on ssc how i defended it to be a Kurdish city way before that flag order thing took place.
i dont know if the mods deleted it but feel free to browse thou khanaqin topic on there.

i just wanted to show jj that Mendeli is slowly getting lost, we dont know for sure the real population, but by that video report the guy who was talking to the tv crew and accompanying it was saying that they are minority he even said he might be killed after this interview.

I've messaged kurdsat on YouTube hopefully they will upload the video i already looked at their videos it is not there.
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
Deleted User
Deleted User

Alan
4th February 2013 - 03:15 AM
no hard feelings on my end, you were thinking about the whole argument in the different way i started realized it after your angry posts lol.

but that article shows kurds are becoming a minority in those two feyli towns as they dont fall under KRG unfortunately , by logic how can such towns which are on the outskirts of KRG turn out this way while Mendeli so far away fro KRG can hold its Kurdish majority up? arabs have been pouring into it like crazy and there is no Kurdish forces to stop it like they do to Khanaqin and Kirkuk.

after milki ordered Kurdish flags to be lowered from Khanqain which "falls" under KRG, he made Kurdish flags removed from Jalawla, Sadiya and Mendeli, then a kurdsat tv crew went to Mendeli and they were stopped by the local police in Mendeli for like 2 hours till Talabani intervened, these 3 towns which are the only 3 Kurdish towns that do not fall under KRG, Hawija is Kurdish too but has now been lost to arabs and you will see 0 kurdish flags there without even milki asking for them to be removed. and since there is no Pesh there to stop arabization, it will get worst day by day to a point of no return.

i dont know what the chances are to save Mendeli from Ilam, but for now Ilam too is occupied, (not persionaized) but occupied dont go all crazy on me for this one too :hi:
Lol heval, I'm not crazy at you. :lol:

Well I don't know in regards for Jalawa, I don't know anyone from there. I know there are Arabs in the district of Mandali, but in the actual town itself it is mostly Kurdish. The reason why I believe that camera crew was stopped was because of my point that it is mostly Kurdish. The Iraqi regime doesn't want to show it like that. Heval how would Mandalwani campaign to be apart of KRG? I am wondering, because my dad says they do want to be apart of it, but he said himself even he doesn't know much.

Well yeh Ilam is occupied, however I remember when I went to Ilam and comparing it to Kirmanshan, it seemed Ilam had less iranian military bases in it. Ilam city had Iranian gaurds, but nothing compared to Kirmanshan, soldiers are everywhere there.
Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


yeah maybe you are right but i want to see myself for sure the town of Mendeli is not lost, actually Talabani's wife visited there last year but there wasnt much discussed in that report apart from some public services to be provided.

here is another article on Jalawla

http://www.aknews.com/en/aknews/3/327723/
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
ALAN
No Avatar


jj i think we should take out discussion to this topic
OnlineProfile Quote Post Goto Top
 
0 users reading this topic
ZetaBoards - Free Forum Hosting
Join the millions that use us for their forum communities. Create your own forum today.
Learn More · Sign-up for Free
« Previous Topic · Photography & Video · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Find more great themes at the Zathyus Network Resources